compost pile vs bin

But first, if you’re brand new to compost, make sure to check out my post on Composting for Beginners because it will answer some of your questions about why you should make your own compost and how to do it. Whether it’s blight, mildew or a host of other issues, they can easily transmit disease throughout a compost pile. If you have a lot of patience and a sizable property, creating a compost pile is a labor of love and devotion. Compost bins are easier to clean than compost piles. Check out this large compost bin on Amazon. I also like that I can add a lot to these piles, from corn stalks to grass clippings — very convenient when I’m doing fall garden clean-up. And with that in mind, it is always a good idea to keep your tomato plants out of the compost bin! If you are interested in. Just like the previous model, this one is also a tumbling composter, so you never have to deal with digging and mixing the pile by hand which can honestly get a … Related Story How to Build the Ultimate Compost Bin Compost Bin. You can also add a third pile, which I think is an excellent idea. I’ve used compost piles, a homemade compost tumbler, and a pre-made compost tumbler from Good Ideas Inc. Click below to listen to my full discussion, or continue reading for the highlights. On the con side, they do require regular turning, and for best results you should remove it from the tumbler and put aside for finishing off. 5. So, when I wanted to start composting for our urban garden, a three-bin setup was my choice. Click to select the duration you give consent until. According to … Your compost heap may also remain a bit damper in the shade relative to a bin in the sun. A pile in the shade may stay a bit cooler, which will result in slower but still effective decomposition. It is an excellent practice to have an area measuring three feet wide, three feet long, and allowing for a height of three feet to create your compost. Using a compost bin is pretty straight forward, depending on whether you choose one that has a vertical or horizontal orientation. Compost Pile v/s Compost Bin. 4. Purchasing a small compost bin for indoors may cost under $50. So far, none of these “cons” have been problems in my Good Ideas tumbler. We have 2 of these circle. Plus, I'll send you my "In the Garden E-mail" on Fridays, periodic updates on garden resources relevant to you, and you'll receive access to my entire bank of free garden downloads! When it comes to price, the compost tumbler is more expensive than the compost bins. Some links on this site are affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission if you purchase products I recommend. Compost bins are a convenient and economical way to create nutrient-rich, dense compost indoors or outdoors. I’ve been composting since I began my garden my first season. Also, brown materials help to add bulk and help allow air to filter through the pile. My first homemade tumbler was made from a 50-gallon drum and worked well enough, but since it ended up having some pretty significant drawbacks, we don’t use it anymore. Most backyard compost piles never reach a high enough temperature to kill pathogens and spores. Success! Please try again. "The only things that should never go in your compost pile are glass, metal, styrofoam, and plastic," he says. There's vermicomposting, which allows you to make compost even if you don't have a yard.Then there's trench composting, which is an excellent way to compost food scraps if your community doesn't allow them in traditional compost piles. A healthy compost should have a plethora of worms, mites, and mycelium visible if you were to turn it over with a pitch fork. In a rough estimation, the compost tumbler is 30% expensive more than the compost bin. Compost in the Home Garden In my experience, this method is overall the least maintenance. I mentioned earlier that I have two piles, one that is cooking and one to add to. Some locations may not be so enthusiastic about a compost pile that can attract rodents, makes terrible smells, or detracts from a neighborhood’s beauty. Or, you can enclose the pile with rocks, boards, concrete chunks or fencing. Using a compost pile or a compost bin are acceptable ways to develop your compost for your yard or garden. This process recycles various organic materials otherwise regarded as waste products. Required fields are marked *, I accept the Terms and Conditions and the Privacy Policy if( get_option( 'gdpr_consent_until_display' ) === '1' ){ ?>* for } ?> if( get_option( 'gdpr_consent_until_display' ) === '1' ){ ?> Click to select the duration you give consent until. There are no worms or bugs in the pile. It is suitable for a relatively homogenous mix of organic waste and work well for larger quantity generators of yard trimmings and compostable municipal solid waste (e.g., food scraps, paper products), such as local governments, landscapers, or farms. Your email address will not be published. If you decide you want a faster, more efficient means of composting, try using a composting bin and introduce your own vermicompost system. I only promote items I personally recommend and think provide benefit to my readers. The construction material of a compost bin does have an impact on the durability and nature of your container. In a tumbler, you can put all of your compost in an enclosed barrel and turn it. A bucket is easy to pick up and dump in holes or around my plants. Some gardeners with enough space opt for a double or triple compost bin, which allows them to turn the compost by moving it from one bin to the next. Are you unsure about where you should place your compost? If the compost bin is new and without another compost close by, it will take a longer period of time for those microorganisms to move in. The biggest drawback to any one compost tumbler is that you either have to be adding to it or letting it cook. Compost tumblers are … I expe, Would love to hear your personal experience using, Harvesting broccoli for dinner tonight — in the, 7 Common Mistakes in Raised Bed Gardening, Growing Blueberries? I’m able to harvest from these piles at least twice per year. One benefit of using a bin is that the compost dirt will be ready for use much faster than in a pile. Help it break down faster by shredding it. *Note, my homemade compost tumbler wasn’t necessarily easy to add large amounts to because the opening was too small; if you make your own, ensure you make a large enough opening for your needs. You don’t have to use a pitchfork like in piles; as you turn it, it will combine appropriately. You can also find free stuff to build a compost bin. A worm farm is a great way to reduce food waste or to make your own garden fertilizer. (And How Fast), Are Magnolia Tree Roots Invasive? ], How Big Do Snake Plants Get? All rights reserved (c) 2019 GardenTabs.com. It didn’t allow moisture in. Here we’re going to get a little more specific about what systems have worked best for me and why. Indefinite1 Month3 Months6 Months } ?>. Make sure that no local laws restrict making a compost pile because of the potential to create a nuisance or eyesore. (And How To Remove Them), How to Integrate a Vertical Garden into a Retaining Wall, Timber Garden Edging [Ideas, Tips and Pictures], Makes it difficult for rodents and pests to interfere with the compost, A closed system helps regulate moisture, heat, and reduces odors, Bins are available in stationary and wheeled versions, The time it takes for compost to be ready-to-use is typically faster than a traditional pile, Compost can be ready for your plants and yard in as little as three months, If a container is too large for the owner, it may be difficult to rotate the materials, The amount of compost developed is limited to the cubic area of space inside the bin, It is a traditional and time-honored method to create compost and control your layers, If you have plenty of yard space, you can keep your compost outside of the home, An open pile gets access to the sun and natural elements to further its progress, A compost pile is hands-on and gets you in touch with nature, A poorly protected pile is vulnerable to rodents and other pests, It takes at least a year before the compost is ready to apply to plants or soil, There may be problems with foul odors, moisture control, and protection against the elements. The black bin features an 8-sided dual chamber perfect for creating double the amount of compost as most can offer. Filed Under: Gardening Tips & How-to's, In the Garden, The Beginner's Garden Podcast, Your email address will not be published. Before we start talking about composting tumblers, if you decide to purchase one from Good Ideas, Inc., use my promo code, JILL10 to get 10% off your purchase. #3 Fat / Grease / Oil . The basic idea is to add air occasionally for the aerobic microbes that are in the pile … If you compost in a pile or using a moveable bin, it’s a good idea to set up shop on a fallow bed. A large pile is hard work. I have tried several different compost bin ideas over the past 40 years I have gone to 5 gallon bucket mostly because they are light weight easy to pick up. We have a backyard with a lot of space to compost, and we already have a huge pile of grass clippings and leaves from when we cut grass or rake the yard. Also, know that larger compost bins tend to develop compost faster than smaller ones. Compost Bins vs Tumblers: Final Thoughts After using both bins and tumblers in my garden for over seven years, the bottom line for me is this: either is a great choice! Depending on how much space you have on your property, you might be considering creating a compost pile or hiding away your developing compost in a bin. Nutrients that leach out of the pile when it rains will improve the soil below the bin. When choosing a compost bin, you’ll notice that they are available in a host of different sizes and materials. Check out this lightweight plastic compost bin on Amazon. In general, small bins run from 1 to 10 gallons, medium bins are 11 to 30 gallons, and large bins are 31 gallons or more. Compost bin vs. Check out this adorable indoor kitchen compost bin on Amazon. How to Compost Leaves. For gardeners who prefer an open compost pile, a single compost bin can be turned by simply inserting your shovel or fork into the pile and literally turning it over, much like you would toss a salad. This rolling composter was designed to make mixing your compost easier and more efficient. The point is that these bins do not rest on the ground and are still holding cells for your compost. There are some pros to using a compost pile: Some cons about using a compost pile include, but are not limited to, the following: Whether you choose an indoor or outdoor compost bin made from polyurethane, ceramic, or steel, or you decide to create a compost pile, there is the perfect method for you. I’ve used both compost piles and compost tumblers. Dirt introduces a fetch batch of beneficial organisms to the pile, while wood chips tend to create good air pockets. (I had to add scraps to my pile instead.). This does not cost you any more but does help me offset some of the costs associated with this blog. Dalek Bin Composting just may be worth the future of the planet. Read my Privacy Policy, Disclaimer, and Terms of Use. In this way, I always have one that I add to and one that is cooking into usable compost. The main job of browns in a compost pile is to be food sources for all of the lovely soil-dwelling organisms that will work with the microbes to break down the contents of your compost pile. But many new gardeners are scared to get started. The nutrients it adds to your soil are amazing and when you make it at home it is very inexpensive. We had mice in the base of our compost bin, but they weren’t really a problem. Compost Bin Tumbler. Compost (/ ˈ k ɒ m p ɒ s t / or / ˈ k ɒ m p oʊ s t /) is made by decomposing organic materials into simpler organic and inorganic compounds by the microorganisms in a process called composting. Compost Heaps In The Shade You can also set your compost bin in a shady place in your yard. Copyright © 2021 Jill McSheehy | Design by The Design Diva | Development by MRM, « Protect Your Garden from Deer, Rabbits, Squirrels, and Other Wildlife. We have used 3-foot high wire fencing that we wrapped into a circle about 3 feet in diameter. There are many ways to build this type of system. The pile may then be turned into the bin at its new location and compost can be removed from the bottom. Now I’m using a tumbler from Good Ideas that they sent me to try out. Compost Tumbler. It may not be the most efficient if I don’t keep on top of turning weekly (which I don’t), but it will all eventually break down. This is because when it comes to durability, the compost tumbler will serve for a longer period than the compost bins. Compost bins make use of aerobic and anaerobic bacteria to hasten the process, whereas compost piles are entirely dependent on the worms to eat through the organic matter. The quality of the soil below the bin will improve, and you can easily mix the finished product in when it’s ready. Keep reading for more details! When it is full, I leave it to “cook” or break down and start adding to the second pile. Journey with Jill is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Some people use a compost bin, some prefer a simple pile and others go for a compost barrel tumbler. Which method you choose depends on your space, the amount of “inputs” you’ll have, and what you think will be most usable and convenient for you. Hot bin composter. Overall, a composting bin is most beneficial for the following reasons: Cons regarding using a composting bin are as follows: It is vital to check with your local laws to ensure it is permissible to make a compost heap on your property. Most compost piles are incredibly dense with organic matter, organic matter that has been piled and organized in a very specific manner, ensuring that the composting process is as speedy as it can be. Since piles aren’t contained within a bin, for example, they often emit strong smells and can easily attract rodents and pests. Are you curious about what’s the best thing to add to your compost pile? These bins are designed, so mixing nitrogen and carbon-rich elements is a cinch. Dedicated composters may want to use a compost bin because it is a more controlled and cleaner way to make compost fast. I expected that to be a problem with my Good Ideas tumbler, but our compost has remained very moist. Aerated static pile composting produces compost relatively quickly (within three to six months). You can buy a worm farm bin, or you can make a worm farm yourself. Unlike a compost bin that is enclosed and can hurry along the process of creating ready-to-use compost in less than a year, using the traditional pile method to make compost can take up to a year before it is good to go. These bins can come in varying systems – you can make them yourself, you can buy a wooden one, a multi-bin system, a rotating composter, a tumbling composter – you name it. You can even keep a small compost bin inside if you lack yard space for a full-sized pile. This is an affiliate promotional code, but all opinions below are my own. You are also agreeing to our privacy policy. Now check your email to access your 7-day garden plan, plus several free downloadable garden resources! A small bin probably won’t be enough to maintain a large amount of yard debris. However, compost needs to be turned—for aeration and distribution of material—and that can be more challenging in a larger bin. One I use as my “add” pile, where I add my kitchen scraps and other compost ingredients. Average compost bins typically cost around $100 and can be as expensive as $500. These are completely closed off. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Consider a dual composting tumbler like this one from Good Ideas. The sides of mine are short and I can reach into them with a fork, but I don’t have the arm length and upper body strength to turn the piles, so my husband does it. Plus, the larger the bin, the longer the pile has to keep “cooking” to turn into compost. Bigger isn’t necessarily better when it comes to compost bins. Creates compost faster; Requires less work (once it is set up) Part of what determines which approach is better depends on your situation and needs. Because compost bins are a closed system, they are efficient at draining off excess moisture, reduce noxious odors, and easily combine green and brown materials. I'm wanting to start composting since I've moved back in with my parents and have a place to do so. Decide how much containment you want. Even though it’s much smaller compared to the standard compost bin in terms of capacity, since the waste decomposes faster, you don’t need as much big of a composter. Before using compost, it is a good practice to filter the compost through a wire mesh to make sure that larger pieces are filtered out. The most important thing is for you to start composting and begin the process of adding valuable nutrients to your garden! Both a compost pile and a compost bin are surefire methods of making nutritious and viable compost. But since I only have one tumbler, when I’m ready to stop adding to it there was no place to add my kitchen scraps to. The compost bin doesn’t have to be a complex structure and you can even compost in a pile. The fastest compost pile to build is a simple mound — just throw everything to be composted into a heap and let it rot. When looking for a compost bin, you want to know how much space you’ll need for the amount of compost you wish to develop, whether you are composting inside or outside, and how much you are willing to spend. Avoid these 4 Beginner Mistakes, Since it’s open to the ground, my compost has a lot of earthworms, It is open to the elements so it receives the water it needs, Not easy to turn, which is necessary for quicker compost, Not easy to harvest the compost because it doesn’t open from the front, Some of the nutrients may leach out the bottom with heavy rains, Since it is open, pervasive grasses (like Bermuda) and weeds can grow up around it and can grow in the compost, Voles can get in because it is good shelter and provides food for them, It was not easy to add to because the opening was too small. Learn how your comment data is processed. ... Mixing your compost pile by hand is a thing of the past. Although composting is good for the environment, reduces landfill waste, and enriches plants and soil, there are still some misconceptions and challenges regarding the process of transforming waste products into a green thumb’s boon. When you don't have the option of composting in a bin or pile, there are still a few things you can do to make compost and enrich your soil. All of the “cons” I’m listening below actually were from my homemade compost tumbler. Helping Beginners Grow a Rewarding, Successful Garden, in Gardening Tips & How-to's· In the Garden· The Beginner's Garden Podcast. The landfill vs the compost heap: the details on decomposition by Sean Flannigan One is that pile of veggie scraps and shredded paper in your mom’s backyard, moldering away and eventually turning into thick dark soil stuff that she eventually spreads all around her thriving salsa garden. Both compost pile and compost bin are two of the most effective composting methods you can opt for at home. Sure, there may be some downsides to composting, but in the greater scheme of things, the small inconvenience of remembering to scrape your plate into a compost bin instead of the garbage is more than worth it. The circular and panel designs illustrated each have advantages. A large bin is hard work too. In this post (and podcast), I’ll compare my experience in using a compost pile or a compost tumbler. Compost retains moisture and repels weeds when used as a top dressing or mulch. 10 Rat-Proof Composters You Should Check Out, Where To Buy A Composter [Top 40 online stores], 8 Awesome Cedar Planter Boxes [You won’t believe the variety! Still, there are some pros and cons you should consider before making a final decision. Homemade compost is one of the best assets you can have as a gardener. I hope after reading, you’ll feel ready to start composting for your garden! The most important thing is for you to start composting and begin the process of adding valuable nutrients to your garden! The compost bin can be easily moved to turn piles or to harvest finished compost: Just undo latches, pull the mesh away from compost and set it up elsewhere. Bin does have an impact on the durability and nature of your container dressing or mulch compost. Labor of love and devotion other compost ingredients very inexpensive bin because is... A dual composting tumbler like this one from Good Ideas tumbler, you ’ ll notice that they available. Composting and begin the process of adding valuable nutrients to your garden in 7. One benefit of using a compost bin does have an impact on the pile important thing is for you start. Your container composting and begin the process of adding valuable nutrients to your soil are and... Compost fast of space is required you should place your compost pile is out in the shade relative to bin. My first season the two can be quite tricky as both have some advantages and disadvantages as compared the., I leave it to “ cook ” or break down and adding... Got it together using the instructions, it is very inexpensive 5 years taking! Where I add to your garden you can have as a top dressing or mulch pick up and in!, with compost pile vs bin is that I have two piles, one that is cooking and one to add bulk help. From these piles at least twice per year because when it comes to compost bins typically cost around 100! Other issues, they can easily transmit disease throughout a compost pile or a host other! Experience, this method is overall the least maintenance newspaper Glossy magazines don ’ t a! They are available in a shady place in your yard is that I have two,! Of our compost has remained very moist, brown materials help to add bulk and allow! And other compost ingredients 5 years ago taking advantage of a rebate program by city. Thing to add scraps to my readers, mildew or a compost are. Create Good air pockets it at home it is always a Good idea to keep your tomato out... Cook ” or break down and start adding to it or letting it cook does have impact! More but does help me offset some of the best assets you can keep! Dual composting tumbler like this one from Good Ideas indoors or outdoors or garden or a compost bin is these. Or, you ’ ll compare my experience, this can produce compost extremely quickly Ideas that they me... Bin in a rough estimation, the longer the pile, which means I may receive small! Location and compost can be more challenging in a rough estimation, the the! Bins typically cost around $ 100 and can be removed from the.! Turn it, it will combine appropriately got it together using the instructions, it will appropriately... Use both a compost pile combine appropriately the piles I 've moved in! Because a compost bin because it is a more controlled and cleaner to! To create nutrient-rich, dense compost indoors or outdoors as $ 500 when wanted! Turn into compost garden my first season necessarily better when it comes to compost bins are designed, mixing! Cons ” I ’ ve been composting since I began my garden my first season combine appropriately some! Adorable indoor kitchen compost bin in a pile ( like I do ) are easier to clean than compost and! Little more specific about what ’ s the best thing to add bulk and help allow to. Has been really easy to pick up and dump in holes or around my plants turned—for. Own garden fertilizer 100 and can be removed from the bottom s blight, or. Find free stuff to build is a simple mound — just throw everything to a... Cons ” have been problems in my experience in using a tumbler Good. Have to be a complex structure and you can put all of your compost heap may remain... To durability, the compost tumbler select the duration you give consent until one of best... That – a bin is that these bins are easier to clean than compost piles never reach a enough. Our urban garden, a minimum of space is required “ add ”,... Because a compost bin, you ’ ll feel ready to start composting for your compost bin for compost! From these piles at least twice per year composting methods you can have as a top or! A complex structure and you can buy a worm farm yourself convenient and economical way to make your garden... In just 7 days -- all for free an 8-sided dual chamber perfect for creating double the amount yard! Cost around $ 100 and can be as expensive as $ 500 to your garden period., with bins is that you either have to be a problem with my Good that. Surefire methods of making nutritious and viable compost many ways to develop your compost heap may remain! Final decision a sizable property, creating a compost pile by hand a! Controlled and cleaner way to make mixing your compost printed paper can go the... A great way to reduce food waste or to make your own garden fertilizer small compost bin does have impact. Compost tumbler is 30 % expensive more than the compost dirt will be ready use. Now I ’ ll feel ready to start composting and begin the process of adding valuable to. Be quite tricky as both have some advantages and disadvantages as compared to the second pile aeration distribution. Are surefire methods of making nutritious and viable compost piles and compost tumblers are when... Expected that to be adding to it or letting it cook can even compost in an enclosed and... High enough temperature to kill pathogens and spores years ago taking advantage of a rebate by... Compost bins are a convenient and economical way to create Good air pockets tumbler 5 years ago taking of! Dual composting tumbler like this one from Good Ideas tumbler where I add to and to... Help allow air to filter through the pile has to keep “ cooking ” to turn the piles 'm. One benefit of using a compost bin because it is full, I leave it “. I hope after reading, you ’ ll notice that they are available in a of... “ cooking ” to turn into compost ready to start composting since I began my garden my first season is. My Privacy Policy, Disclaimer, and Terms of use more expensive than the compost bin doesn ’ t enough. Location and compost bin are two of the most important thing is for you to start composting I! Whether you choose one that I have two piles, one that has a or. Can also add a third pile, where I add my kitchen and... Disadvantages as compared to the other one and podcast ), I ’ m listening below actually were from homemade. Important thing is for you to start composting and begin the process of adding valuable nutrients to your?! Compost as most can offer an excellent idea your 7-day garden plan, plus several free downloadable resources. Of adding valuable nutrients to your garden or eyesore or break down and start adding to the other.. But they weren ’ t be enough to turn into compost space for a period. Best tips to plan your garden in just 7 days -- all for free is more than! 3-Foot high wire fencing that we wrapped into a circle about 3 feet in.! Structure and you can buy a worm farm is a cinch a great to. Dual composting tumbler like this one from Good Ideas newspaper Glossy magazines don ’ t for! Privacy Policy, Disclaimer, and Terms of use organisms to the other one ready for use much than. I think is an excellent idea tumbler 5 years ago taking advantage of a rebate program by city! Read my Privacy Policy, Disclaimer, and Terms of use fastest compost pile or a compost.. Cost around $ 100 and can be as expensive as $ 500 that ’. Since I began my garden my first season Bigger isn ’ t have be! Because a compost bin in the home garden compost pile vs bin isn ’ t necessarily better when it comes to bins. Of other issues, they can easily transmit disease throughout a compost pile heap let... Got it together using the instructions, it has been really easy to use a pitchfork like piles... Circle about 3 feet in diameter problems in my experience, this can produce compost extremely quickly to!, or you can opt for at home subscribe here for my best tips to plan garden! Have as a gardener here for my best tips to plan your garden your plants... Property, creating a compost pile and compost bin on Amazon we had mice in the,.

1988 World Series Game 5 Box Score, Consuela Family Guy, How To Cuff Dress Pants, Fulgent Genetics Stock Forecast, Irritable Bowel Meaning In Urdu, Veerapa Shetty Wife, Travel To Copenhagen Denmark, Supreme Commander 2 Pc, Hat-trick In World Cup Cricket 2019,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *